Eight people lost their lives on Wednesday night. Nicole Daniela Salvada Rodriguez, 9. Kevin Santiago Reyes Gonzalez, 10. Gabriel Siguencia, 22. Barry Mamadou, 23. Edgar Sapon, 26. Jose Luis Caguana Cosquillo, 26. Juan Daniel Salvada Guzman, 31. Ndiaye Mamadou, 31. Families lost their homes, neighbors, and loved ones. We grieve with them and stand with the survivors, displaced residents, and families of the workers who were killed.
Tenants across the city know this incident was neither singular nor spontaneous. It was man-made.
For decades, the landlord of 1321 Flatbush collected rent from a neglected building and ignored tenants’ basic requests for repairs. Isolag Realty and Olufemi Falade treated the tenants of 1321 Flatbush like a revenue source, not like human beings. Rent was extracted, not reinvested in safety. 1321 Flatbush collapsed because this already precarious structure was further stressed by the rushed construction of new apartments next door, carried out by developers made out to be our supposed saviors in the “housing crisis.”
City leaders stated, “If there is anyone or any entity operating in this city that bears responsibility for what happened, we will hold them fully accountable.”
Let us be clear. 1321 Flatbush collapsed due to city negligence. The collapse is the predictable result of a system that puts landlord and developer profit ahead of tenant safety. The building had 98 open housing code violations and the DOB already issued a stop order to Robert Fischman’s company, Berkoff Supply, for unsafe work conditions next door. Fischman ignored the city’s stop order and continued working anyway. The problem is not just a lack of laws to protect tenants; it’s that the city does not enforce these laws even when they exist. Violations pile up for decades, stop-work orders are ignored, and landlords and developers learn that cutting corners costs less than keeping people safe. There were warnings, and those warnings were ignored. Working class Black and brown tenants pay for that calculus with their lives.
This is not new. Our neighbors have exposed the exact conditions that lead to tragedies like these for decades. Our ceilings are collapsing, our walls are full of mold, our fire escapes are crumbling, and our homes are rat-infested. The rent goes up, and the super’s hours go down. Meanwhile HPD and DOB continue to give us the run-around and prioritize landlord profits and developer timelines.
So while we support and welcome the city’s efforts to hold those who bear responsibility for this disaster accountable, we expect it to mean everyone: landlords, developers, and the agencies that failed to act—the individual failures as well as root causes.
After a similar landlord-driven tragedy in Madrid, tenants responded with a historic outpouring of organizing and mass solidarity. We must do the same. Deep, long-term, democratic organizing is our best defense against corrupt developers, negligent landlords, non-union contractors, pro-development liberals, and underfunded and ineffective city bureaucracy. We will not allow tenants to bear the burden of this crisis while those with power avoid responsibility.
Over the coming weeks and months, TUF is committed to supporting survivors, listening to and organizing with our neighbors, and collectively developing a set of concrete demands that targets the complicity between landlords, developers, and the government that led to this disaster.
Grieve, rage, donate, march. Knock on your neighbors’ doors and organize your building. Together, we must build the power to never let this happen again.